Best Pizza in St. Nicholas, Jacksonville, FL
2 pizzerias in the St. Nicholas area
Pizzerias in St. Nicholas
Tiny family-owned evening operation in St. Nicholas serving pizza from a walk-up carryout window on Beach Boulevard, Tuesday through Sunday, with delivery available.
Neighborhood pizzeria on Beach Boulevard near St. Nicholas, hand-tossing New York-style thin crust alongside Sicilian thick-crust pans, calzones, and strombolis.
About St. Nicholas
St. Nicholas is one of Jacksonville's oldest neighborhoods, sitting just east of San Marco where Atlantic and Beach Boulevards begin their run toward the ocean. It is a modest, historic district that has started drawing new energy as San Marco's momentum spills over.
Its pizza is delightfully unpretentious: a walk-up carryout window serving evening pies, and neighborhood shops hand-tossing New York thin crust and Sicilian pans. This is the stretch for a no-fuss pie on the way home.