Best Pizza in Neptune Beach, FL
8 pizzerias in the Neptune Beach area
Pizzerias in Neptune Beach
A Jacksonville classic since the 1980s, serving hand-tossed, thin-crust New York-style pies with fresh dough made daily across several Northeast Florida locations.
Jacksonville Beach slice shop from a 19-year-old first-time owner, selling classic New York cheese slices and 18-inch whole pies in the evenings, with cupped pepperoni earning quick local buzz.
Locally operated Jacksonville Beach outpost of the thin-crust Edge-to-Edge toppings brand, open late with delivery, dine-in, and pickup a few blocks from the ocean.
Calabrian family Italian dinner spot in Neptune Beach built around wood-fired artisan pizza and handmade pasta, open Wednesday through Saturday evenings. Also caters events from a vintage horse-trailer pizza rig.
Beaches Town Center dinner-house anchor of 25-plus years, where a dedicated wood-fired pizza list shares the menu with house-made pastas and nightly live music, steps from the Neptune Beach oceanfront.
Family-owned since 1998 on the 3rd Street corridor in Jacksonville Beach, turning out New York-style pies and calzones alongside Sicilian-rooted pasta dishes and a full bar.
Greek family counter spot on Mayport Road that has paired gyros and Mediterranean plates with New York-style pizza, stromboli, and calzones since 2003.
Founded by two Italian brothers in 1976, Renna's serves New York and Sicilian-style pizza with traditional toppings across several local shops.
About Neptune Beach
Neptune Beach sits just north of Jacksonville Beach around the Beaches Town Center, a low-key, walkable hub shared with Atlantic Beach. It is a quieter, residential beach community with a tight-knit feel.
Pizza here is classic and family-friendly: New York and Sicilian-style pies from longtime local names. It is the kind of place where the same families have been ordering the same pie for years.