Best Pizza in Murray Hill, Jacksonville, FL
5 pizzerias in the Murray Hill area
Pizzerias in Murray Hill
Delivery-and-carryout shop from the Florida-grown Five Star chain, covering Murray Hill, Avondale, Riverside, and downtown with big pies until midnight on weekdays and 2 a.m. on weekends.
Old-school Westside Italian-American spot on Normandy Boulevard turning out pizzas, baked pastas, and homemade marinara, with weekday lunch and early-evening dinner hours.
A Murray Hill favorite known for its soft crust, rich tomato sauce with Italian seasonings, and hand-cut vegetables. Build your own by the slice or the pie.
A father-and-son team converted a 1995 school bus into a wood-fired kitchen parked on Cassat Avenue, serving evening-only pies with imported Italian sauce and handmade mozzarella since late 2023.
Murray Hill's Neapolitan specialist, baking pies in a wood-fired oven with imported Italian 00 flour and water treated to mimic Brooklyn's. Also turns out wings and wood-fired sandwiches.
About Murray Hill
Murray Hill is a historic, increasingly hip neighborhood just west of Riverside, with a revived stretch of Edgewood Avenue full of indie shops and casual eateries. It has a strong neighborhood feel and a loyal local crowd.
The pizza here leans classic and unpretentious: soft crust, rich tomato sauce, hand-cut toppings, the kind of place regulars order from every week. A solid bet for a no-fuss, build-your-own slice or pie.