Best Pizza in Fleming Island, FL
4 pizzerias in the Fleming Island area
Pizzerias in Fleming Island
Big, relaxed family-owned Italian gastropub in Fleming Island's Town Center pairing brick-oven pies with pasta, burgers, and craft beer on tap, open late on weekends.
Stone-baked pizza on a spring-water crust with an extensive vegan and gluten-free menu and a deep craft-beer list. Several locations across the city.
Small family-owned Fleming Island shop across from Fleming Island High School doing foldable New York thin crust plus wings and pizza rolls. A true takeout-first neighborhood slice joint.
Authentic Neapolitan wood-fired pizza baked in brick ovens made in Italy, using San Marzano tomatoes and organic ingredients. Multiple Northeast Florida locations.
About Fleming Island
Fleming Island stretches along US 17 south of Orange Park, a planned-community corridor of golf courses, waterfront neighborhoods, and the Town Center shopping district that anchors most of its dining.
Pizza options run from a big family brick-oven gastropub with craft beer on tap to a takeout-first New York slice shop across from the high school, with national build-your-own spots filling the gaps. For Clay County families, pizza night does not require crossing the Buckman.