Best Pizza in Baymeadows, Jacksonville, FL
4 pizzerias in the Baymeadows area
Pizzerias in Baymeadows
A Jacksonville classic since the 1980s, serving hand-tossed, thin-crust New York-style pies with fresh dough made daily across several Northeast Florida locations.
Family-run operation that grew from a 2021 food truck into a Baymeadows dine-in restaurant, offering New Haven-style pies from the brick oven, New York-style pizza, and New England grinders.
Baymeadows spot covering both New York and Chicago-style pizza plus calzones, stromboli, and burgers, with a kitchen open to midnight on weekends. One of the few late-night options in the corridor.
Founded by two Italian brothers in 1976, Renna's serves New York and Sicilian-style pizza with traditional toppings across several local shops.
About Baymeadows
Baymeadows is a dense, diverse residential and commercial area in southeast Jacksonville, known for one of the city's best concentrations of international food. Pizza holds its own in the mix.
You will find established New York and Sicilian pizzerias here, including longtime family names serving the area for decades. A dependable part of town for a classic pie and delivery.